Bilgin Çiftçi

A Turkish Court Is Trying to Figure Out if It’s an Insult to Compare the President to Gollum

Gollum, a special effects creature from the movie 'Lord of the Rings', is on display at the annual four-day Comic Con convention in San Diego, July 18, 2003. Thousands of fans from around the world gather to peruse a collection of comic books and industry related sci-fi, video and motion picture fantasy products. REUTERS/Mike Blake PP03070072 MB - RTRTBV

The man who made the comparison faces up to two years in prison

A court in Turkey has solicited experts to conduct a character assessment of Gollum, from The Lord of the Rings, because the judge is unsure if a comparison between the character and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is insulting.

In October, a physician named Bilgin Ciftci was fired from his job at the Public Health Institution of Turkey after he shared a meme that juxtaposed Gollum (a slimy, menacing humanoid) and Erdogan in a series of postures, the Turkish newspaper Today’s Zaman reports.

Cifti now faces up to two years in prison for insulting the President, though he claims that Gollum is not a “bad character,” the paper says.

Neither the prosecutor nor the judge presiding over the case has seen The Lord of the Rings film adaption series in its entirety, so the court has brought in two academics, two behavioral scientists and a media expert to determine if Cifti did indeed seek to insult the President.

The hearing has been postponed until February 2016.

The BBC reports that 105 people were indicted in Turkey between August 2014 and March 2015 for “insulting the head of state.” The country’s press freedom ranks 149th out of 180 nations.

 

A Turkish Court Is Trying to Figure Out if It’s an Insult to Compare the President to Gollum